HOME   People do good because they are human, not because they are religious! 

Do not give God any credit for the good they do, they did it!

 

COMPARING RELIGION AND ATHEISM

Problem

Fundamentalism, that is putting belief before people

Religion
 
Has beliefs and in danger of leading to fundamentalism. Jesus sanctioned fundamentalism when he said that we must love God and declare that God matters more than any person.
 
Atheism
 
Has no religious beliefs. Atheism is not the denial that God exists though many atheists do deny he exists. Atheism is rather the absence of belief in god or gods. Christians are atheists after all as far as Zeus is concerned. They don't believe in the gods of paganism. There is no possibility of fundamentalism in relation to atheists.

Atheism is purely a negative stance in the sense that it is the absence of belief. The bloody regimes of say Communism were not based on the absence of belief but on their own kind of faith. Atheism cannot be blamed for what the Communists did.

Problem

Dogmatism, dogmatism is the attitude that "We are right and we are not going to change no matter what the evidence says".

Religion

Based on dogma.

Atheism

Atheists all have different ideas and approaches to life. They make suggestions but do not enforce these suggestions as dogma. The atheist who is dogmatic is really approaching religion in his attitude. The proper atheist doesn't do that.
 
Atheists do not see beliefs as truth. Beliefs should be taught as beliefs and not as truth though you can hope they are the truth. Religion seeks control of schools to teach beliefs as truth. Jesus sanctioned this bigotry when he said that he was the Truth.
 
Problem
 
Disrespect towards religious belief

Religion

The Bible insults and mocks the Gods and beliefs of other faiths. To insult a belief is to insult the God of truth that gave the belief and must be punished under blasphemy law. Religion should not be criticised.
 
Atheism
 
Satire and mockery of religion may be necessary to stop it doing harm in the world. These tools make great impact. Religious beliefs are only human creations and everything human should be examined and we should have the right to say why we disagree with it. Religion itself has to contradict other religions and criticise to exist. For example, Islam teaches that the Christian notion of God having a Son called Jesus who is also God is extreme blasphemy. The Bible and Church says of the heretic, "Let him be anathema".
 
Conclusion

It is obvious what the best view is...
 
APPENDIX

Religion should be defined as a system of authority supposedly set up by a supernatural or magical being. And it may be that one religion is 99% supernatural and another is only 2%. The atheist does not feel obligated to believe there is no God. It is not an authority thing. The atheist is depending on evidence and reason. The atheist cannot be considered a religious person. What adds to the confusion when atheism is taken for a religion is that some faiths are considered religious when they are not. For example, Buddhism denies that any god has the right to tell you what to believe or do thus its gods are not real gods. We must remember too that the distinction between the miraculous or divine and the magical is mere semantics. You cannot say atheists are part of a religion of their own, atheism, for there will be more differences between one atheist and the next one than there is between a Christian and a Muslim and you cannot say Christianity and Islam are really the one religion.

Most believers do not care about truth. Yes, it is obvious that most religious people do not care about truth in the philosophical or religious sense. Even if religion could be a good thing, how could it when that is most people's attitude? As an Irishman living in Ireland, one can get a savage rebuke for saying anything critical of priests or Catholicism. And its alarming how religious people can be told a truth and go on as if they are deaf and were not told it at all.

Are people insinuating: "Atheist, you think religion is so stupid? Well, your atheism is just another religion, so you are also stupid! Hah!". Believers are trying to accuse atheists of being hypocrites. The insinuation shows that believers seem to suspect that religion is stupid! If atheism were a religion it might be the only smart one! It may condemn religion without hypocrisy when it defines religion as submission to some magical authority such as God (in reality it means submission to men who claim authority was given by God to them over you!). Accusing secularism and atheism of being religions is a common religionist tactic to encourage society to oust both from the public sphere in the name of the doctrine that faith and politics need to be kept separate! The plan is to fill the vacuum with say the Christian religion! Its crazy!

Why is belief in God the most effective at brainwashing or conditioning people? We expect religion to know how to brainwash people! Atheism cannot! Surely let that be a warning about faith in God!!